1 winner and the rest of you losers

Matthew Marquand has been following the boardgame T-shirt racket for a while, most recently with Uberbadger. I went so far as to propose a shirt:

I would like a shirt with a graphic something akin to a large digit ‘1’ above the word “winner”, and the words “and the rest of you losers” written in a circle about that.

A rapid exchange with Matthew lead to the following sequence of designs:

Plus an external suggestion from Chad Krizan of:

A quick conversation with Ariel Seoane (Seo) on BGDF’s chat then lead to these suggestions:

Variously capitalising on suggesting a poker chip or classical smilie face model. BTW: The typo is known – the image is a quick sketch, not a final product.

The question is now which image is more interesting to buyers?